Woah slow down! You buy Lumber and nails at the hardware store right? Why are you getting keys cut there?!?! Is it just me or does the guy cutting the keys there look like he would have a hard time figuring out where they plug into the car?
Going to the hardware store for keys is like shoping for parts at the big name generic autoparts store. It is possible that you will get what you want, but not very likely.
I too fell victim to the mindset that it's not that damn hard to cut a key, why does it matter where I get it done? Then one day I tried to get a copy cut of my last worn out ignition key for a 80 Camaro. Four hardware stores cut me keys and took my money. not one worked. I was panicked. I thought I was going to have to replace the ignition. Then, out of the blue a friend asked me a simple question. Did you try a locksmith? "A professional?" I thought. Could the skill of the operator really make a difference? Oh HECK YA it does! One cut, one key. No snaggs, and hesitation, just in and turn. Ever since I have had all my keys cut at a locksmith and boy what a difference! I have taken in keys that were almost nothing but a stick left, and not only can they copy them, they can actually cut them larger, restoring the key back to it's original width! NEVER have I been told they don't have my key. NEVER have I had to say "yes you do, it's right here" and pull it off the rack myself. And most importantly, I have NEVER had a locksmith sell me a key that does not work. What has occured to me since is that all those hardware store keys with their bad cuts were damaging my locks. They didn't fit quite right, and were a little tough to turn, but after a while they always started to work better. I wasn't seeing wear on the key surface, but SOMTHING has to be breaking in for the operation to become smooth over time........
Locksmiths are skilled tradespeople. Please don't disregard them by taking your keys to a hardware store. You wouldn't have your quarterpanel replaced by Macco would you?