** EFI Survey ** - please participate [Archive] - Chevelle Tech

: ** EFI Survey ** - please participate


Al
Feb 3rd, 05, 3:06 PM
http://www.chevelles.com/Electronic.gif

We were asked if Team Chevelle could help with gathering data about EFI from a large aftermarket company and thought it would be a good idea, besides, he is a TC member :D

It applies to carbs as well, is very short and will help out the hobby.

The survey is now over. Thanks!!

Al

Pat Kelley
Feb 3rd, 05, 3:27 PM
done!!

Troy70SS
Feb 3rd, 05, 4:05 PM
Me too!

Never Satisfied
Feb 3rd, 05, 4:32 PM
Me three...

docaudio
Feb 3rd, 05, 4:45 PM
Hey Al,
I tried to send it in, but it gave me an error "Missing Reference - Access Denied" Any ideas???
Thanks,
Bill

RedSS454
Feb 3rd, 05, 4:48 PM
me four...

wayner
Feb 3rd, 05, 4:49 PM
Me five

GRN69CHV
Feb 3rd, 05, 6:01 PM
Not sure if mine went through also.

Al
Feb 3rd, 05, 6:24 PM
Bill, you must have hit it while I was making a minor change. I modified a couple fields and added the option for your techname.

Thanks guys.

67malibuEFI
Feb 3rd, 05, 6:42 PM
done

TD509EFI
Feb 3rd, 05, 6:49 PM
Me seven ( I think smile.gif )

John

Tom Mobley
Feb 3rd, 05, 6:51 PM
me too.

67RAT
Feb 3rd, 05, 6:55 PM
graemlins/thumbsup.gif 67rat

Importtech
Feb 3rd, 05, 7:14 PM
Done

Slowpoke70
Feb 3rd, 05, 8:21 PM
Done. I'll take a free one!

Bob West
Feb 3rd, 05, 8:47 PM
I recommended the HP950 :D

Jim Elliott
Feb 3rd, 05, 8:50 PM
Completed

jnorth
Feb 3rd, 05, 9:43 PM
I'm in. smile.gif

Gazzer
Feb 4th, 05, 12:18 AM
950HP & a Performer RPM :D

Gaz

Big Dre 72
Feb 4th, 05, 12:42 AM
DONE

David Bates
Feb 4th, 05, 5:07 AM
What the heck, it's only money! I'll take two.

Keith Tedford
Feb 4th, 05, 5:21 AM
Our everyday vehicles are fuel injected and there is no denying the smoothness. How much power is there to be gained with port injection over a well setup carb and intake? For the price of fuel injection it would want to be considerable. I guess a big block with injection would have a nice wow factor at the cruises.

SS4speed
Feb 4th, 05, 12:38 PM
Done also.

Slowpoke70
Feb 4th, 05, 12:41 PM
I would be more interested in getting PROOF that the EFI set-up could perform very well on the street and highway as opposed to the carb'd set up. I'd rather them advertise that the systems have been road tested in the real world, on a real daily driven car. All this stuff would be more important to me than if they advertised a certain amount of HP/TQ over the carb'd system. Everyone says you can tune a carb to HP/TQ the same or better than EFI. The point of EFI is the ability to tune with pin point accuracy and reliability/efficiency of EFI.

So instead of advertising power, I offer these up for a change:

1. Real world road testing.
2. The ability to super-tune the fuel and ignition curves to your liking. Ability to store different codes (one track, one highway, etc).
3. Efficiency as compared to a carb'd set up. How much MPG better can it do?
4. Ability to MATCH the HP/TQ numbers of a well tuned carb and ignition.

That's my take on it.

ZZ69chevelle
Feb 4th, 05, 4:35 PM
I tried to submit but got some goofy error.

Missing Referrer - Access Denied
Your browser did not send a Referer header with this request, so it is not possible to check that the referring page is allowed to access this program. :confused:

Tino
Feb 4th, 05, 6:37 PM
Done!

Doug F.
Feb 4th, 05, 9:30 PM
Slowpoke,
I've tuned dozens of EFI engines, some back to back with a carb (I'm talking 900 HP Dominator equipped engines). Here are some comments.

1. Real world road testing - there are 1000's of miles of real world testing on many of the aftermarket EFI setups. They work. If you are in KY stop by and I will give you a ride in my Nova that will have a 255@.050 solid roller 491 BBC in it. It will fire right up at 30 deg F and drive perfectly, it had a decent solid roller 388 EFI engine in it that is how it performed.
2. All the laptop programmable EFI system have the ability to tune the fuel and timing very precisely. If you have a wideband O2 sensor you can tell it what A/F to run at at different loads and RPM points. No lean spots, no rich spots, period.
3/4 - The KEY to aftermarket EFI systems is how well it is tuned. How much MPG?? Take a 355 with a pig rich carb and of course the EFI will make a lot more MPG if it is tuned right. Take a super tuned Q-Jet that runs at 15:1 and if your EFI runs at 14.7:1, you might not see much. The EFI give more ability to use an OD trans which is a key to better fuel economy.

Take a dead-on set up carb that is fully tuned and they will make about the same power, that requires a lot of knowledge and changes, along with a wideband A/F meter to know what you are doing with a carb. The hard part is make a lean area correct and another goes to rich. With EFI the tuning points are all independent. 90% of the time I can beat a carb by a little.

There are no cut-and-dry answers which is a frustration of mine when people make blanket statements. You can't say it will always do this or that. Depends on every application. That goes for a lot of parts for that matter.

To truly appreciate aftermarket EFI you have to ride/drive a car with it. Nobody is going to pay $2000 for 10 HP, but there is a lot more to it than that. Take a car with a big solid roller that idles great at 800 RPM cold or hot in neutral or in gear.

I go to the track with a laptop and in 1 minute stick a "track only" program in it, race and change to another file and go home. I have an internal ECU datalogger I can log passes with and see wheelspin, converter performance, shift points, etc.

There are a lot of other benefits over a carb.

chev crazy
Feb 5th, 05, 1:16 AM
Just entered mine Al.

7DSS
Feb 5th, 05, 1:23 AM
Completed mine too.

Slowpoke70
Feb 5th, 05, 2:08 AM
Originally posted by Doug F.:
Slowpoke,


To truly appreciate aftermarket EFI you have to ride/drive a car with it. Nobody is going to pay $2000 for 10 HP, but there is a lot more to it than that. Take a car with a big solid roller that idles great at 800 RPM cold or hot in neutral or in gear.

I go to the track with a laptop and in 1 minute stick a "track only" program in it, race and change to another file and go home. I have an internal ECU datalogger I can log passes with and see wheelspin, converter performance, shift points, etc.

There are a lot of other benefits over a carb. That's exactly what I'm talking about. I could care less about a 10HP claim, you can get your carb worked on or switch to another carb to make up for that. That's not what counts. What counts is what you said, all the cool things you can do with the EFI set up. Compatibility/reliability and creature comfort is what you're paying for in EFI.

undee70ss
Feb 5th, 05, 5:57 AM
Done

johnnyr
Feb 5th, 05, 7:32 AM
Done.

jarsmith2
Feb 5th, 05, 9:40 AM
Hope it helps.

Rumblin70SS
Feb 5th, 05, 12:01 PM
Done and hope it helps also!! I'd like to be a part of the development!! :cool:

JOEL_TX
Feb 5th, 05, 12:48 PM
Got my $.02 in as well.

Slowpoke70
Feb 5th, 05, 1:20 PM
Originally posted by ac72rat:
Good clean get yer feet wet starter 69 for sale
What does that have to do with EFI?

LXS
Feb 5th, 05, 4:30 PM
Done! graemlins/thumbsup.gif

Greg Eacker
Feb 5th, 05, 5:35 PM
Put in my setup and opinion. Am gonna be standing by my front door waiting for the tech team to come and install my free EFI that I suggested they do to get my endorsement. I'll keep the lights on for you.

19Nova72
Feb 5th, 05, 11:10 PM
Done

mechcanic427
Feb 6th, 05, 3:42 PM
it be done

stroobydoo
Feb 6th, 05, 9:22 PM
graemlins/thumbsup.gif Done

Sgtpop
Feb 7th, 05, 5:15 AM
So be it, I reckon so!

SS_Dave
Feb 7th, 05, 9:25 AM
Done 2 or 2 Done
one of those.

I have been seriously tinking of fuel injection.
Has been too expensive though. And, It really should not be. Espically with the throttle body type.

71454Chevelle
Feb 7th, 05, 11:29 AM
Done graemlins/thumbsup.gif

TWC
Feb 7th, 05, 8:32 PM
I'm in

chloverbear
Feb 7th, 05, 8:36 PM
Done!

69chevelle355
Feb 8th, 05, 10:03 AM
finished

docaudio
Feb 8th, 05, 6:36 PM
I've tried several times to submit the form but am still getting an error message just like ZZ69chevelle. :confused:

I think going to an EFI setup is a little like going to HDTV. It's new for a lot of folks, a bit pricy now, but if more and more people take the plunge, prices should come down as manufacturers recoup their R&D costs. Also, EFI usually (in a really tunable system) requires a least a basic comfort level with computers in your car, which may be the more challenging factor for manufactures to contend with. Even though my system is not on the road yet, my initial tests show a scary ammount of throttle response, bucketloads of useful info to dial everything in, and having a laptop mounted to your dash really gets the 'tuner' crowd looking! graemlins/thumbsup.gif
Just my $.02
-Bill

Crazyhorse
Feb 8th, 05, 7:56 PM
Done, and I just went to HDTV, does this mean...well maybe not.

chevydog66
Feb 9th, 05, 11:19 PM
Kewl, maybe they will send out a new EFI to all of us who replied!!!!

SS_Dave
Feb 11th, 05, 10:57 AM
Originally posted by chevydog66:
Kewl, maybe they will send out a new EFI to all of us who replied!!!! One could only dream.

SS MPSTR
Feb 11th, 05, 11:08 AM
Done.

motown/malibu
Feb 11th, 05, 1:57 PM
completed

Elusive_R
Feb 11th, 05, 10:17 PM
Survey done! However, I'm claiming dibs on any prototypes that may come for free. After all, I am a starving college student....

Ryan

66rat
Feb 12th, 05, 8:12 AM
Gotter done

Grandpa's SS
Feb 12th, 05, 11:33 PM
Me to, me an EFI, and I will build a forced induction with it.

71350SS
Feb 13th, 05, 10:13 AM
Done.

FireRescueFL
Feb 13th, 05, 11:12 AM
I'd be willing to try it (even though I don't really like electronics in my old cars) if they could sell a whole system for what I can buy a top end Holley for. I know the prices have gone down a lot in the past few years but until I can get one for about a grand, I won't switch. Oh yeah, and even if they are only a grand, I still won't buy one that's not MACINTOSH COMPATIBLE!

---Chris

Parrydise7
Feb 15th, 05, 12:06 PM
graemlins/thumbsup.gif

blazerbob
Feb 16th, 05, 7:55 PM
Great Survey! Would like to see others suggestions and what they thought! :cool:

smittyocat
Feb 17th, 05, 7:51 PM
I dooed it also graemlins/thumbsup.gif

70mousejob
Feb 19th, 05, 4:34 PM
done!

Big Block Dave
Feb 19th, 05, 7:14 PM
It was short, but not as enjoyable as my first digital exam

TJ1967SS
Feb 20th, 05, 5:13 PM
Having an ECU in your car is no big deal. I mounted mine on the outside top of the glove box liner. You wouldn't know it was there except the comm cable that lives inside the glove box now. And you guys are right, the tuner crowd doesn't know what to think when I'm clicking away on the laptop at the car wash.

andrewb70
Feb 23rd, 05, 8:17 AM
They think you are dialing in your NOOOOOOOOOOOOOS....

LMAO

Andrew

Al
Feb 23rd, 05, 3:57 PM
Thanks for the responses.
If you were thinking about filling it out but haven't, this is the last day for the survey. I'll be removing it on Thursday, the 24th.

Al